Previous Article
News
Co-creation to balance real-world research and practice
An article by Kieran McCartan, Professor in Criminology, University of the West of England
Evidence based practice is the gold standard that we all strive for! We want to know that something works before we implement it, before it impacts our professional practice, the lives of our clients and the broader community. This is particularly important in the field of criminal justice, especially when you are dealing with high risk individuals, their assessment, management and integration; where the consequences of getting something wrong can be significant and damaging on several levels. As professionals we are held accountable for the decisions that we make, both in terms our failures and our successes; therefore, we need to be sure that we are working in an informed and effective way. This means that we must balance what we know, through our experiences and knowledge, about what works with people who have committed serious offending and what the prescribed, accepted, approved processes and interventions are. Which can result in a quandary, how do you move practice forward at a pace that recognises innovation, evaluation and responsible risk management?
Involve practitioners
We need to be constantly committed to research, develop an effective, fit for purpose evidence base and with practice being rooted in robust, empirical working; however, this takes time and costs money! The challenge of evidence-based practice is that you need to wait for the evidence to develop which means ongoing research projects concluding, recommendations being taken on and implemented. Which takes time and is often juxtaposed to lived reality where things often need to be implemented immediately. We end up in a situation where everything changes, or nothing changes, where the pendulum swings being effectively evidence-based policy and emotionally driven populist public policy. This is a narrative that hear a lot in criminal justice, implement change quickly and then discover that it may not work the way that we want it. Attending conferences and taking with professionals and practitioners across the criminal justice spectrum I often hear “but it does not work in practice” or “our hands our tied, this may not work but its what we have to roll out”, all of which leaves staff feeling undervalued, underappreciated and silenced. This is problematic, we need to value the experience and knowledge of professionals and practitioners because as frontline staff they are the ones working with clients (or people with a criminal conviction) daily, seeing what works and what does not. We need to trust and rely upon our staff and their knowledge base in, they need to be involved in developing evidence-based practice not simply being informed of it. It is important to recognise the need for practice informed research, which means that staff and clients need to be involved in the process and that it cannot simply be left to external, independent researchers not linked, or tied into real world practice.
We need a paradigm shift back to the days of co-creation because the most important thing in effective risk management is collaboration and partnership working, therefore it stands to reason that the most important aspect of developing an evidence base is the same. The relationship between the professional research advisory boards and/or the involvement of research-practitioner in collaboration with the external academic is essential. The only way that we know if any research is fit for purpose and the outcomes will function in practice is through partnership working. The model of research into practice co-creation has faded somewhat over the last number of years with a focus on externally commissioned completely independent research, which was then followed by all research moving in house and being non-independent to, what some would say, a position of no research being done in practice or a token gesture towards research. Research, in the main, has become about justifying policy and evidencing current practice, which although important cannot be the limits of research as it also has to be about innovation. Practitioners and professionals need to feel invested in the research that impacts their working so that they understand where it has come from and can implement it appropriately. Co-creation and collaboration results in an upskilled workforce that is critical, understands the role of research and thinks with an analytical frame as well as a practice based one; meaning that all staff being evidence based and research informed! This upskilling means that staff use their research grounding, developed through their training and maintained by professional development, in an effective way daily and that their decisions become evidence informed. It means that professional development becomes relevant, it becomes more that “I have to attend this course so I can get the CPD points” or “I’m reading this article in my spare time because I have to”. Staff need to become invested in the research and practice that means something to them and develops their working lives in a meaningful way.
Effective collaboration
What does an effective research and practice collaboration look like in real terms? Co-creation means that professionals and practitioners can help set the research agenda, they can enable researcher to address real world concerns that are faced in practice through informed evaluations or innovate intervention development and roll out. Research in practice needs to become rooted in action research methodologies, where the tools that used are fit for purpose and that the recommendations are implemented as the research progresses. As everyone is involved in the development and execution of the research, then everyone is aware of the outcomes and how they fit into practice and therefore change, through evidence-based practice, becomes organic and not post-hoc.
Related News
Keep up to date with the latest developments, stories, and updates on probation from across Europe and beyond. Find relevant news and insights shaping the field today.
New
CEP Board
CEP board visit France
16/11/2026
On 13 November 2026, the CEP Board visited its French member organisation, the Direction Générale de l’Administration Pénitentiaire of the French Ministry of Justice. The visit coincided with the final CEP Board meeting of the year, hosted by CEP Vice-President Mr Daniel Danglades, who represents the French institution.
Recap
Framework Decisions
Recap: annual meeting of the Expert Network on Framework Decisions 829 and 947
09/11/2026
On Thursday 5 November an annual meeting of the Expert Network on Framework Decisions 829 and 947 took place online. Bringing together 20 participants from 12 EU jurisdictions including representatives of the Academy of European Law and European Judicial Network, the meeting provided an opportunity to exchange experiences, discuss current implementation challenges and identify priorities for enhancing cross-border cooperation in the application of the two Framework Decisions.
New
Education and Training, Probation in Europe
Justice programme: the judicial training call is open for applications!
09/11/2026
Are you ready to help address the training needs of justice professionals from different EU countries in the fields of civil law, criminal law and fundamental rights? This call supports cross-border training projects contributing to the effective and consistent application of EU law. In line with the new European Judicial Training Strategy, the call also supports the digitalisation of justice. Don’t miss this opportunity! Apply by 4 March 2027, 17:00 Brussels time.
Recap
CEP Board, Foreign Nationals in Prison and Probation, Probation in Europe
CEP at the 16th Plenary Meeting of the Council for Penological Co-operation
06/11/2026
From 3 to 5 November 2026, representatives of the Confederation of European Probation (CEP) participated in the 16th Plenary Meeting of the Council for Penological Co-operation (PC-CP).
New
CEP
Newsletter October 2026 out now
29/10/2026
CEP’s latest newsletter is out now! It includes:
- Deadline approaching for the Workshop on Technology and Alternatives to Detention
- Recap of the 14th EM and CEP Excellence Leadership Training
- New publications from Expert Groups on Technology and Expert Group on Violent Extremism
- Call for Proposals: Evaluation of CEP Expert Groups
- Engaging with Research – a new section in our newsletter
- and much more!
New
Violent Extremism
Understanding Youth Radicalisation: What Can Probation Services Do? | New Report from CEP’s Expert Group
27/10/2026
In recent decades, the violent radicalisation of juveniles and young adults has become a pressing concern for policymakers, researchers, practitioners, and communities worldwide. While considerable attention has been devoted to psychological vulnerabilities, socio-economic marginalisation, and community-level influences, the broader context in which violent radicalisation develops is often overlooked. At the same time, the increasing involvement of young people in violent extremist offences highlights the urgent need for effective prevention efforts. Addressing youth radicalisation has become a complex and evolving challenge for families, educators, mental health professionals, law enforcement agencies, probation services, and security authorities.
Subscribe to our bi-monthly email newsletter!
"*" indicates required fields
- Keep up to date with important probation developments and insights.